If They Could See What Nurses See: Health Care Reform Passes

Opening Skies photo: JParadisi

     I wish declaring war on Iraq had stirred the same amount of energy which Health Care Reform has. Each endeavor involves spending huge sums of money and pivots on lives in the balance.

     The anger of those opposing Health Care Reform is vehement. Crowds shouting slurs at senators, threatening them with violence in voice messages for voting in favor of the bill, while prominent citizen and member of the opposition Sarah Palin tweets Don’t Retreat, instead RELOAD! to her followers demonstrates that no one is safe from bullying and workplace violence

     I would like Health Care Reform to go further, still, it’s a big step towards the betterment of the lives of our citizens. Its importance became real to me last week, just days after the bill’s passage, as I listened to young patients living with treatable, chronic illnesses tell me that they are enrolling in college, or taking the job offered to them, because they no longer have to plan their lives around qualifying for disability payments for their pre-existing conditions. Hearing young adult patients express how a future of independence has suddenly opened up for them, because Health Care Reform passed brought tears to my eyes. I wonder if those who oppose Health Care Reform are so blind that a tear could not escape from their eyes too, if they could see what nurses see.

Workplace Violence: What’s Bizarre is Accepting it Happens

Use the Call Light for Help photo: JParadisi 2010

     Blogger Theresa Brown, RN’s post for the NY Times,  Violence on the Oncology Ward  struck a chord within me. My own experiences with violence directed at nurses started while I was a nursing student during a clinical rotation over 20 years ago. Standing in the courtyard of a large urban hospital under a bright noonday sun, someone grabbed me from behind by the hair while screaming obscenities in my ear. My head was jerked backwards against my shoulder so violently that the only thing I could see was a classmate and a passerby running towards me to fend off the attacker. After the two rescuers pried the fingers that were beyond my grasp loose from my hair, I saw that the attacker was a diminutive woman dressed in filthy rags. I stood stunned as she walked down the sun-drenched sidewalk, still shouting obscenities. When I reported the incident to my clinical instructor, expecting her to warn the rest of our class to be careful, she told me disinterestedly that “It was just a crazy person, it doesn’t count.” I realized that both the “crazy woman” and myself had been dismissed.      

     Years later, in another hospital, a patient came to his appointment with a butcher knife in his back pocket. That hospital has a no tolerance policy for weapons of any kind, and security was quick to take the knife surrendered voluntarily by the patient so he could receive care. After security left, the patient looked coolly into my eyes and said “I don’t know why you’re worried about the knife, I could beat you to death with my crutch if I wanted to.” The security officer returned, and the patient was escorted off campus.      

      He took himself to the emergency department, and told his story to a nurse there. This nurse called my department. Listening to the story, he commented “That’s bizarre,” after every statement I made. I finally asked him “What’s bizarre?” and he said, “That you feel he threatened you, after security took the knife.” No longer a student nurse, I asserted myself: “He did threaten me.” The ER nurse said, “I find it bizarre. That kind of thing happens all the time over here.”       

     “What’s bizarre,” I told him, “is that you accept it happens.”      

     Studies of workplace violence suggest that accepting  inappropriate behavior in the health care environment creates a setting conducive to more serious forms of violence. Verbal or physical threats, and carrying any weapon or item that can be used to cause death or serious physical injury are only two examples of inappropriate behavior. 

     I wonder if a sense of duty to the patient blurs what is acceptable behavior for some nurses? Despite his threatening behavior, I arranged another method of care for my patient with the knife, because he needed treatment.  

     I don’t know if enacting legislation mandating tougher penalties for workplace violence committed against nurses is the answer. It seems to me that everyone needs protection from violence. What I do know is that violence towards nurses is still accepted by many in the profession as an inevitable part of our job description, and I strongly disagree.